Spotlight on SIG etcd

By Frederico Muñoz (SAS Institute) |

In this SIG etcd spotlight we talked with James Blair, Marek Siarkowicz, Wenjia Zhang, and Benjamin Wang to learn a bit more about this Kubernetes Special Interest Group.

Introducing SIG etcd

Frederico: Hello, thank you for the time! Let’s start with some introductions, could you tell us a bit about yourself, your role and how you got involved in Kubernetes.

Benjamin: Hello, I am Benjamin. I am a SIG etcd Tech Lead and one of the etcd maintainers. I work for VMware, which is part of the Broadcom group. I got involved in Kubernetes & etcd & CSI (Container Storage Interface) because of work and also a big passion for open source. I have been working on Kubernetes & etcd (and also CSI) since 2020.

James: Hey team, I’m James, a co-chair for SIG etcd and etcd maintainer. I work at Red Hat as a Specialist Architect helping people adopt cloud native technology. I got involved with the Kubernetes ecosystem in 2019. Around the end of 2022 I noticed how the etcd community and project needed help so started contributing as often as I could. There is a saying in our community that "you come for the technology, and stay for the people": for me this is absolutely real, it’s been a wonderful journey so far and I’m excited to support our community moving forward.

Marek: Hey everyone, I'm Marek, the SIG etcd lead. At Google, I lead the GKE etcd team, ensuring a stable and reliable experience for all GKE users. My Kubernetes journey began with SIG Instrumentation, where I created and led the Kubernetes Structured Logging effort.
I'm still the main project lead for Kubernetes Metrics Server, providing crucial signals for autoscaling in Kubernetes. I started working on etcd 3 years ago, right around the 3.5 release. We faced some challenges, but I'm thrilled to see etcd now the most scalable and reliable it's ever been, with the highest contribution numbers in the project's history. I'm passionate about distributed systems, extreme programming, and testing.

Wenjia: Hi there, my name is Wenjia, I am the co-chair of SIG etcd and one of the etcd maintainers. I work at Google as an Engineering Manager, working on GKE (Google Kubernetes Engine) and GDC (Google Distributed Cloud). I have been working in the area of open source Kubernetes and etcd since the Kubernetes v1.10 and etcd v3.1 releases. I got involved in Kubernetes because of my job, but what keeps me in the space is the charm of the container orchestration technology, and more importantly, the awesome open source community.

Becoming a Kubernetes Special Interest Group (SIG)

Frederico: Excellent, thank you. I'd like to start with the origin of the SIG itself: SIG etcd is a very recent SIG, could you quickly go through the history and reasons behind its creation?

Marek: Absolutely! SIG etcd was formed because etcd is a critical component of Kubernetes, serving as its data store. However, etcd was facing challenges like maintainer turnover and reliability issues. Creating a dedicated SIG allowed us to focus on addressing these problems, improving development and maintenance processes, and ensuring etcd evolves in sync with the cloud-native landscape.

Frederico: And has becoming a SIG worked out as expected? Better yet, are the motivations you just described being addressed, and to what extent?

Marek: It's been a positive change overall. Becoming a SIG has brought more structure and transparency to etcd's development. We've adopted Kubernetes processes like KEPs (Kubernetes Enhancement Proposals and PRRs (Production Readiness Reviews, which has improved our feature development and release cycle.

Frederico: On top of those, what would you single out as the major benefit that has resulted from becoming a SIG?

Marek: The biggest benefits for me was adopting Kubernetes testing infrastructure, tools like Prow and TestGrid. For large projects like etcd there is just no comparison to the default GitHub tooling. Having known, easy to use, clear tools is a major boost to the etcd as it makes it much easier for Kubernetes contributors to also help etcd.

Wenjia: Totally agree, while challenges remain, the SIG structure provides a solid foundation for addressing them and ensuring etcd's continued success as a critical component of the Kubernetes ecosystem.

The positive impact on the community is another crucial aspect of SIG etcd's success that I’d like to highlight. The Kubernetes SIG structure has created a welcoming environment for etcd contributors, leading to increased participation from the broader Kubernetes community. We have had greater collaboration with other SIGs like SIG API Machinery, SIG Scalability, SIG Testing, SIG Cluster Lifecycle, etc.

This collaboration helps ensure etcd's development aligns with the needs of the wider Kubernetes ecosystem. The formation of the etcd Operator Working Group under the joint effort between SIG etcd and SIG Cluster Lifecycle exemplifies this successful collaboration, demonstrating a shared commitment to improving etcd's operational aspects within Kubernetes.

Frederico: Since you mentioned collaboration, have you seen changes in terms of contributors and community involvement in recent months?

James: Yes -- as showing in our unique PR author data we recently hit an all time high in March and are trending in a positive direction:

Unique PR author data stats

Additionally, looking at our overall contributions across all etcd project repositories we are also observing a positive trend showing a resurgence in etcd project activity:

Overall contributions stats

The road ahead

Frederico: That's quite telling, thank you. In terms of the near future, what are the current priorities for SIG etcd?

Marek: Reliability is always top of mind -– we need to make sure etcd is rock-solid. We're also working on making etcd easier to use and manage for operators. And we have our sights set on making etcd a viable standalone solution for infrastructure management, not just for Kubernetes. Oh, and of course, scaling -– we need to ensure etcd can handle the growing demands of the cloud-native world.

Benjamin: I agree that reliability should always be our top guiding principle. We need to ensure not only correctness but also compatibility. Additionally, we should continuously strive to improve the understandability and maintainability of etcd. Our focus should be on addressing the pain points that the community cares about the most.

Frederico: Are there any specific SIGs that you work closely with?

Marek: SIG API Machinery, for sure – they own the structure of the data etcd stores, so we're constantly working together. And SIG Cluster Lifecycle – etcd is a key part of Kubernetes clusters, so we collaborate on the newly created etcd operator Working group.

Wenjia: Other than SIG API Machinery and SIG Cluster Lifecycle that Marek mentioned above, SIG Scalability and SIG Testing is another group that we work closely with.

Frederico: In a more general sense, how would you list the key challenges for SIG etcd in the evolving cloud native landscape?

Marek: Well, reliability is always a challenge when you're dealing with critical data. The cloud-native world is evolving so fast that scaling to meet those demands is a constant effort.

Getting involved

Frederico: We're almost at the end of our conversation, but for those interested in in etcd, how can they get involved?

Marek: We'd love to have them! The best way to start is to join our SIG etcd meetings, follow discussions on the etcd-dev mailing list, and check out our GitHub issues. We're always looking for people to review proposals, test code, and contribute to documentation.

Wenjia: I love this question 😀 . There are numerous ways for people interested in contributing to SIG etcd to get involved and make a difference. Here are some key areas where you can help:

Code Contributions:

  • Bug Fixes: Tackle existing issues in the etcd codebase. Start with issues labeled "good first issue" or "help wanted" to find tasks that are suitable for newcomers.
  • Feature Development: Contribute to the development of new features and enhancements. Check the etcd roadmap and discussions to see what's being planned and where your skills might fit in.
  • Testing and Code Reviews: Help ensure the quality of etcd by writing tests, reviewing code changes, and providing feedback.
  • Documentation: Improve etcd's documentation by adding new content, clarifying existing information, or fixing errors. Clear and comprehensive documentation is essential for users and contributors.
  • Community Support: Answer questions on forums, mailing lists, or Slack channels. Helping others understand and use etcd is a valuable contribution.

Getting Started:

  • Join the community: Start by joining the etcd community on Slack, attending SIG meetings, and following the mailing lists. This will help you get familiar with the project, its processes, and the people involved.
  • Find a mentor: If you're new to open source or etcd, consider finding a mentor who can guide you and provide support. Stay tuned! Our first cohort of mentorship program was very successful. We will have a new round of mentorship program coming up.
  • Start small: Don't be afraid to start with small contributions. Even fixing a typo in the documentation or submitting a simple bug fix can be a great way to get involved.

By contributing to etcd, you'll not only be helping to improve a critical piece of the cloud-native ecosystem but also gaining valuable experience and skills. So, jump in and start contributing!

Frederico: Excellent, thank you. Lastly, one piece of advice that you'd like to give to other newly formed SIGs?

Marek: Absolutely! My advice would be to embrace the established processes of the larger community, prioritize collaboration with other SIGs, and focus on building a strong community.

Wenjia: Here are some tips I myself found very helpful in my OSS journey:

  • Be patient: Open source development can take time. Don't get discouraged if your contributions aren't accepted immediately or if you encounter challenges.
  • Be respectful: The etcd community values collaboration and respect. Be mindful of others' opinions and work together to achieve common goals.
  • Have fun: Contributing to open source should be enjoyable. Find areas that interest you and contribute in ways that you find fulfilling.

Frederico: A great way to end this spotlight, thank you all!

For more information and resources, please take a look at :

  1. etcd website: https://etcd.io/
  2. etcd GitHub repository: https://github.com/etcd-io/etcd
  3. etcd community: https://etcd.io/community/